Mr. Goodwin is everything you want in an attorney: professional, honest, thorough, and genuinely caring. He always explains things clearly, so I understood exactly what was happening and what to expect next. His attention to detail and persistence really stood out. Looking back, I feel lucky to have found him. He guided me through the whole process expertly, and I deeply appreciate all his hard work. Would definitely recommend him to anyone needing legal help.
Call Today:
212-233-1233
Classic and Vintage Car Attorney in New York
As a New York attorney with extensive courtroom experience and a deep understanding of both automotive history and state vehicle law, We are a law firm that represents owners, buyers, collectors, restorers, and enthusiasts resolve complex legal disputes involving antique, classic, vintage and collector vehicles.
Why Vintage Car Owners Need Specialized Legal Representation
Owning a classic car, whether it's a 1967 Shelby GT500, a vintage Porsche 911, or a pre-war Ford, involves unique legal challenges that typical car owners never encounter. From 1950s Chevrolets to 1980s BMWs, each vintage vehicle represents not just transportation, but a significant financial investment and piece of automotive history.
Classic car legal issues in New York require an attorney who understands both vehicle law and the collector car market. Since starting my practice in 2008, I've helped hundreds of clients navigate complex legal matters, and I bring that same dedication and expertise to vintage vehicle cases.
Common Legal Issues for Classic Car Owners in New York
Title and Ownership Problems for Vintage Vehicles
Title disputes are among the most frequent legal issues vintage car owners face in New York. Unlike modern vehicles with complete digital records, classic cars often have missing or incomplete title documentation. Common problems include:
- VIN discrepancies or non-standard vehicle identification numbers
- Estate inheritance complications when acquiring vintage vehicles
- Bills of sale that don't meet NYS legal requirements
- Ownership disputes on vehicles with 50+ year histories
- DMV requiring an indemnity bond when proof of ownership is incomplete
Key rule: Under VTL §2102, vehicles model year 1973 and newer require a certificate of title in New York. Vehicles model year 1972 and older do not receive titles and instead use a transferable registration as proof of ownership. When proof of ownership is insufficient for titled vehicles (1973 and newer), DMV may require an indemnity bond under VTL §2105. The bond amount is determined by the DMV Commissioner and is typically equal to one and one-half times the vehicle's value as a safeguard against competing ownership claims.
These title problems can prevent DMV registration or result in losing your collector car to someone claiming prior ownership. I work directly with the New York DMV's Title Services Bureau to obtain bonds when necessary, clear defects, and resolve ownership disputes.
New York DMV Registration for Classic and Antique Vehicles
New York has two main registration options for older vehicles: Historical Plates (HX/HM) and Vintage (Year-of-Manufacture) Plates.
Under VTL §401, a historical motor vehicle means any vehicle manufactured more than 25 years prior to the current calendar year. Both historical and vintage plates are restricted to vehicles owned and operated as exhibition pieces or collector's items, used for club activities, exhibits, tours, parades, occasional transportation and similar uses, but not for general daily transportation.
Inspection rules: Under New York law, all registered vehicles must pass an annual safety inspection covering brakes, steering, suspension, tires, lights, windshield, wipers, horn, mirrors, seat belts, and fuel systems. Vehicles 25 model years or older are exempt from emissions testing under 6 NYCRR Part 217, but they remain subject to the annual safety inspection requirement. There is no age-based exemption from safety inspections in New York.
Common DMV issues include:
- Applying for Historical or Vintage plates
- Resolving VIN verification problems at DMV offices
- Transferring out-of-state classic registrations
- Dealing with DMV title rejections due to documentation gaps
- Navigating collector vehicle insurance requirements
Classic Car Insurance Disputes in New York
Agreed value insurance for collector cars operates differently than standard auto coverage. Insurance disputes I handle include:
- Disagreements over valuation after accidents or total loss
- Denied claims for undisclosed modifications or restoration work
- Coverage issues for damage during transport or at car shows
- Salvage title complications affecting insurability
- Mileage restrictions and usage limitations in policies
- Disputes with Hagerty, Grundy, American Collectors Insurance, and others
After investing $50,000 to $500,000 or more in your vintage vehicle, an insurance dispute can devastate your finances. I challenge lowball settlement offers, work with classic car appraisers, negotiate with specialty insurers, and file bad faith insurance claims when warranted.
Buying and Selling Classic Cars: Legal Protection
Classic car transactions involve substantial money and require careful legal documentation. Common issues include:
- Misrepresentation of condition, authenticity, or history
- False “numbers matching” or “all original” claims
- Fraudulent documentation or cloned VINs
- Contract disputes when sellers refuse to complete sales
- Auction purchase problems (Barrett-Jackson, Mecum, RM Sotheby’s, etc.)
- Disputes over included parts, manuals, and provenance
New York’s Used Car Lemon Law (General Business Law §198-b) requires dealers—defined as anyone who sold three or more cars in the past 12 months—to provide a limited warranty on qualifying used cars. It does not apply to private sales, vehicles manufactured before 1984, or cars with more than 100,000 miles. Because of these restrictions, most antique and classic vehicles fall outside the law’s coverage.
Since many classic cars exceed the law’s mileage and age thresholds—or are bought directly from private sellers—the Used Car Lemon Law rarely protects collectors. That means most disputes over vintage car sales must rely on other legal theories, such as fraud, misrepresentation, or breach of contract.
Before committing to a purchase or sale, I review agreements for warranties, payment terms, inspection contingencies, return/refund rights, and dispute procedures.
Mechanic’s Liens and Restoration Shop Disputes
Many vintage car restoration projects result in legal problems, such as:
- Mechanic’s liens placed on vehicles for disputed charges
- Shops failing to complete work or performing substandard repairs
- Storage facilities holding vehicles hostage for unpaid bills
- Restoration costs exceeding original estimates
- Shops closing or going bankrupt while holding your car
Under Lien Law §184, mechanics and storage facilities in New York can place liens on your classic car for unpaid repair, storage, or towing bills. However, they must follow strict notice and sale procedures under Lien Law §§200-202 before they can legally sell your vehicle. Section 201 requires a 10-day payment demand and service via certified mail, while Section 202 specifies public auction requirements for property valued over $100.
Importing Classic Cars to New York
Importing vintage vehicles involves complex federal and state regulations. Under 49 U.S.C. §30112 and 49 CFR §591.5, vehicles at least 25 years old from the date of manufacture are exempt from Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards without requiring modifications. This is the DOT/NHTSA exemption.
The EPA exemption under 40 CFR §1068.315 allows vehicles 21 years or older to be imported without meeting current emissions standards, but only if they remain substantially in their original configuration.
Additional requirements include:
- U.S. Customs documentation and duties
- Completing EPA Form 3520-1 and DOT Form HS-7 at entry
- Proper New York State titling procedures for imported vehicles
Why Choose a Lawyer Who Understands Classic Cars?
Generic attorneys often don’t understand the collector car world. As both a classic car enthusiast and attorney, I recognize the difference between “driver quality” and “concours” restorations, why “numbers matching” matters for value, how provenance affects authenticity, and how market values differ across marques and models.
My Approach to Client Service
At the Law Offices of Albert Goodwin, I provide client-centered service — accessible, responsive, and focused on your goals. With over 17 years in courtrooms, millions recovered for clients, and a strong reputation for integrity, I bring the same commitment to excellence to every vintage car case.
Frequently Asked Questions About Classic Car Legal Issues
- How much does a classic car lawyer cost in New York? Legal fees vary. I offer free consultations and work on hourly or contingency arrangements depending on your case.
- Can I register a classic car without a title in New York? It depends on the vehicle's age...
- What qualifies as a historic vehicle in New York? Under VTL §401...
- Do I need a lawyer to buy a classic car? Not legally required, but highly recommended...
- How long do I have to file a lawsuit over a classic car purchase? It depends on the type of claim...
- What should I do if a mechanic won’t release my classic car? Contact an attorney immediately...
- Can I sue if someone sold me a fake or misrepresented classic car? Yes. Remedies exist for fraud, misrepresentation, and breach of contract under New York law.
Protect Your Classic Car Investment Today
Your vintage vehicle represents passion, history, and significant value. Don’t let legal issues threaten it.
If you’re facing legal challenges with your classic, antique, or collector vehicle — or want your next transaction protected — contact me today for a free consultation.
Law Offices of Albert Goodwin, PLLC
Manhattan Office:
31 W 34th St, Suite 7058
New York, NY 10001
Tel: 212-233-1233
Fax: 646-929-5595
Brooklyn Office:
300 Cadman Plaza West, 12th Floor
Brooklyn, NY 11201
Tel: 718-509-9774
Email: [email protected]
Website: nyestateslawyer.com
Evening & weekend appointments available. Video consultations offered.
Albert Goodwin, Esq.
Classic Car Attorney | Vintage Vehicle Lawyer
Licensed in New York State and Florida
Hofstra University School of Law, 2007
Over 17 Years of Courtroom Experience
Serving collectors, restorers, and enthusiasts throughout New York State since 2008
About the Author
Albert Goodwin Esq. is a licenced New York attorney with over 17 years of courtroom experience. His extensive knowledge and expertise make him well-qualified to write authoritative articles on a wide range of legal topics. He can be reached at 212-233-1233 or [email protected].
Albert Goodwin gave interviews to and appeared on the following media outlets:
