New York courts can appoint two people to manage the finances of an adult who can no longer handle them. Under Article 81 of the New York Mental Hygiene Law (MHL), these people are called co-guardians of the property. Other states, California among them, call the same role a co-conservator of the estate. New York repealed its conservatorship and committee statutes when Article 81 took effect in 1993, so New York petitions, orders, and court forms say "guardian," not "conservator."
This page covers three situations:
An Article 81 proceeding is brought in the Supreme Court, or in the County Court outside New York City, in the county where the alleged incapacitated person (AIP) lives or is physically present (MHL §§ 81.04, 81.05). The petition may name more than one proposed guardian. MHL § 81.19 allows the court to appoint one or more individuals, a not-for-profit corporation, or certain other entities.
The court may appoint a guardian only if it finds that the appointment is necessary and either that the person agrees to it or that the person is incapacitated (MHL § 81.02). Incapacity must be shown by clear and convincing evidence that the person is likely to suffer harm because he or she cannot manage property or personal needs and cannot adequately understand and appreciate the nature and consequences of that inability. In Matter of Maher, 207 A.D.2d 133 (2d Dep't 1994), the Appellate Division held that a court must also consider whether existing resources, such as a valid power of attorney or health care proxy, already meet the person's needs. If they do, no guardian, single or co, should be appointed.
When the court signs the order to show cause, it ordinarily appoints a court evaluator under MHL § 81.09. The evaluator meets the AIP, explains the proceeding, reviews finances and medical information, interviews the proposed co-guardians, and reports to the court on whether each proposed co-guardian is suitable. The court may also appoint counsel for the AIP under MHL § 81.10. The hearing must generally be held within 28 days of the signing of the order to show cause, and the AIP has a right to be present (MHL § 81.11).
MHL § 81.19(d) directs the court to consider, among other things, any nomination made by the person, the proposed guardian's relationship with the person, the person's wishes, and the proposed guardian's ability to carry out the duties. Courts apply these factors to each proposed co-guardian separately. A court can appoint one sibling and decline to appoint the other, or pair a family member with a professional or institutional co-guardian when the estate is large or the family is divided.
The duties of every guardian are set out in MHL § 81.20. Property management powers come from MHL § 81.21, and personal needs powers come from MHL § 81.22. Co-guardians do not have to hold identical powers. A common arrangement names one family member guardian of the person under § 81.22 and appoints that person and a second individual as co-guardians of the property under § 81.21. Because Article 81 favors the least restrictive form of intervention (MHL § 81.01), the order should grant only the powers the person's actual limitations require.
The order and judgment, and the commission issued to the co-guardians, define how they may act. New York has no default rule in Article 81 that answers this question for every case, so the order should state it directly. Vague orders are the most frequent source of later motions. Three structures are used.
The provisions below show how proposed orders commonly address shared authority. They are examples for discussion only. They are not a form, and the wording any court adopts depends on the judge, the county, and the facts.
Joint authority:
ORDERED that [Name] and [Name] are appointed co-guardians of the property of [Name], an incapacitated person, and shall exercise the powers granted herein jointly, such that no disbursement, transfer, investment, or conveyance shall be made without the written consent of both co-guardians; and it is further ORDERED that all guardianship accounts shall require the signatures of both co-guardians for any withdrawal.
Several authority with limits:
ORDERED that the co-guardians may each act severally with respect to the payment of the incapacitated person's ordinary living expenses, provided that any single disbursement exceeding $[amount], and any sale, mortgage, or lease of real property, shall require the joint written consent of both co-guardians and prior approval of this Court.
Divided authority:
ORDERED that co-guardian [Name] shall be responsible for the collection of income, payment of household and care expenses, and maintenance of the incapacitated person's residence, and co-guardian [Name] shall be responsible for the management of investment and retirement accounts; and it is further ORDERED that each co-guardian shall provide the other with monthly statements of all accounts under his or her management.
Orders may also include a dispute clause directing the co-guardians to apply to the court, on notice to the court examiner, if they cannot agree within a set number of days.
An appointed guardian cannot act until the clerk issues a commission. Before that happens, each co-guardian generally must file the required qualifying papers, including a designation of the clerk to receive process (MHL § 81.26) and any bond the court requires (MHL § 81.25). Each co-guardian must also complete the guardian education program required by MHL § 81.39 unless the court waives or modifies that requirement.
Under MHL § 81.25, the court may require a property guardian to post a bond in an amount it sets based on the assets and income under management. With co-guardians, the court may require a bond from each, a single bond covering both, or no bond, for example where funds are held in accounts that cannot be withdrawn without court order. Bond premiums are ordinarily paid from the incapacitated person's estate. Independent authority over liquid assets usually leads to a higher bond than a joint-signature or restricted-account arrangement.
Guardianship accounts are opened under the incapacitated person's Social Security number and titled to show the guardianship, for example "[Co-Guardian A] and [Co-Guardian B], Co-Guardians of the Property of [Name]." Banks review the commission and the order before opening or retitling accounts. If the order requires joint action, the bank will usually set up dual-signature requirements and may decline online banking or debit cards that one co-guardian could use alone. Some orders direct that certain funds be held in restricted accounts from which nothing can be withdrawn without a further court order. Co-guardians should give the bank a certified copy of the order early, since branch staff often need legal department review.
MHL § 81.28 ties a property guardian's compensation to the commissions allowed to trustees under SCPA 2309, subject to the court's approval. How that compensation is divided between co-guardians depends on the order and the court's application of the statute. Courts often allow a single commission shared between the co-guardians, and some orders allocate it according to the work each performs. Family members serving as co-guardians sometimes waive compensation. The order should address this issue so the court examiner and the co-guardians are not left to argue about it at the first annual account.
Both co-guardians sign and are responsible for the reports, even if one did most of the bookkeeping. Each co-guardian should keep separate copies of statements, receipts, and correspondence and review the full account before signing. If the examiner finds unexplained transactions, the court may surcharge one or both co-guardians for the loss. For help preparing or challenging an account, see our page on fiduciary accountings.
Each co-guardian is a fiduciary in his or her own right. Deferring to the other co-guardian is not a defense. A co-guardian who knows, or should know, that the other is misusing funds must object, refuse to participate, and, if necessary, apply to the court. Silence in the face of a co-fiduciary's misconduct can expose the passive co-guardian to liability. Our page on breach of fiduciary duty in New York explains how these claims are brought.
Co-guardians who must act jointly cannot override each other. The usual remedies are:
The following is a hypothetical, offered to show how the remedies fit together. Two sisters serve as joint co-guardians of the property of their father, who lives in a nursing facility. His Queens house sits empty, and carrying costs are draining his savings. One sister wants to sell. The other refuses, hoping to move in later. Either sister could move for instructions and for authority to sell, which requires court approval under the order in any event. The court would weigh the father's wishes, his finances, and his Medicaid planning needs. Options open to the court include authorizing the sale over the objection, modifying the order to give one sister authority over the real property, or, if the conflict is affecting the father's care, removing one or both sisters and appointing a neutral guardian. The standard throughout is the incapacitated person's best interest, not the co-guardians' preferences.
One co-guardian can be removed without ending the guardianship. If a co-guardian resigns (MHL § 81.37), dies, or becomes unable to serve, the court decides whether the remaining co-guardian continues alone or whether a successor is appointed (MHL § 81.38).
If you are a co-conservator appointed in California and your conservatee is moving to New York, you generally do not start over with a new Article 81 petition. New York and California have both adopted versions of the Uniform Adult Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Jurisdiction Act. New York's version is MHL Article 83. California's version is the California Conservatorship Jurisdiction Act, Probate Code §§ 1980 and following. California's act does not apply to Lanterman-Petris-Short (LPS) mental health conservatorships, so this process is for probate conservatorships.
Transfer is the right choice when the conservatee is moving to New York permanently. It is a two-court process:
In accepting the transfer, the New York court recognizes the California order, including its finding of incapacity and its appointment of the co-conservators. The New York court does not simply retry incapacity from the beginning.
Registration fits when the conservatee stays in California but has New York assets, such as a bank account or a Manhattan co-op. Article 83 allows a conservator appointed in another state to register the order in New York, if no guardianship petition is pending here, by filing certified copies of the order and letters in the appropriate New York court after giving notice to the appointing court. Once registered, the co-conservators may exercise in New York the powers granted by the California order, except as New York law prohibits. Some New York institutions and title companies will still ask questions about an out-of-state order, so registration should be handled before a sale or account closing is scheduled.
Most states have adopted the uniform act, so the same transfer and registration procedures usually apply to conservators and guardians appointed in New Jersey, Florida, and many other states. Confirm that the appointing state has enacted the act and review its version before filing.
For an adult with an intellectual or developmental disability, families often use Article 17-A of the Surrogate's Court Procedure Act instead of Article 81. Article 17-A proceedings are heard in Surrogate's Court and rest on medical certifications of the disability rather than a functional incapacity hearing of the Article 81 type. Parents commonly petition together as co-guardians, and SCPA § 1757 allows the court to name standby and alternate guardians so that authority passes without a new proceeding when a parent dies or can no longer serve. A 17-A guardianship generally gives broader authority than a limited Article 81 order, and New York courts and the legislature have been reconsidering that breadth. Article 17-A property powers are also more limited, so families with significant assets may need Article 81 or a special needs trust. The right choice depends on the person's diagnosis, abilities, and finances.
A durable power of attorney under New York General Obligations Law Article 5, Title 15, a health care proxy, and a funded revocable trust can make a guardianship unnecessary. When co-agents under a power of attorney disagree or one is misusing authority, Article 81 can still be used. MHL § 81.29 permits the court to modify or revoke a power of attorney or health care proxy only in limited circumstances. See our pages on advance directives in New York and responding to an agent who abuses a power of attorney.
The Law Offices of Albert Goodwin represents:
We draft proposed orders that state how authority is shared, work with court examiners on reports and objections, and coordinate with California counsel on transfers. We have offices in New York City, Brooklyn, and Queens. Call 212-233-1233 or email [email protected].
This article provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice. Statutes and court practices change, and guardianship outcomes depend on the facts of each case and the discretion of the court. Reading this page does not create an attorney-client relationship.