Beneficiaries of New York estates often come to us with the same worry. The lawyer handling the estate won't answer their questions, seems to take the executor's side on every issue, or sends documents to sign with no explanation. Sometimes this is a genuine problem. More often it reflects how estate representation works in New York. This page explains who the estate's lawyer actually represents, what the conflict-of-interest rules say, how to tell a legitimate concern from a misunderstanding, and what you can do in Surrogate's Court and through the attorney discipline system.
Who the Estate's Lawyer Represents
When someone dies, the Surrogate's Court issues letters testamentary to an executor named in a will, or letters of administration to an administrator if there is no will. That person is the fiduciary. The lawyer who files the probate or administration petition and guides the estate through the process is the fiduciary's lawyer. The beneficiaries are not the lawyer's clients.
For beneficiaries, this has several practical effects:
- Advice: The estate's lawyer gives legal advice to the executor or administrator. The lawyer is not required to advise you about your rights and generally should not try to.
- Privilege: Communications between the fiduciary and the estate's lawyer are generally protected by attorney-client privilege. Under CPLR 4503(a)(2), the fiduciary relationship between the executor and the beneficiaries does not, by itself, waive that privilege.
- Disputes: If you and the executor disagree about how assets are valued, sold, or distributed, the estate's lawyer will advance the executor's position. That is the lawyer's job, not a betrayal.
- Documents you are asked to sign: A waiver of citation, a consent to probate, or a receipt and release is prepared for the executor's benefit. You can have your own lawyer review it before you sign.
The fiduciary, by contrast, owes duties to you. An executor or administrator must act loyally and prudently for the benefit of all beneficiaries. If the executor is the one acting against your interests, the remedy runs against the fiduciary in Surrogate's Court, and the estate's lawyer may become a witness or a participant in that dispute. Our page on beneficiary and executor conflicts covers those disputes in more detail.
Red Flags Specific to Estate Matters
Some situations do warrant a closer look. In estate and trust matters, the concerns we see most often include:
- Dual roles without written consent: The estate's lawyer also represents a creditor, a claimant against the estate, or one beneficiary in a dispute with others, and there is no record of informed consent confirmed in writing.
- Unexplained legal fees charged to the estate: Large or recurring payments to the estate's lawyer with no invoices or explanation. Attorney fees paid from estate funds are subject to review by the Surrogate's Court.
- No accounting: The executor and the lawyer refuse to provide any information about assets, debts, or expenses long after letters were issued.
- The drafting attorney benefits under the will: The lawyer who drafted the will is named as executor or receives a gift under it. New York has specific rules for both situations, discussed below.
- Self-dealing by the fiduciary that the lawyer facilitates: Estate property sold to the executor or a relative at a below-market price, or estate funds mixed with the executor's personal accounts.
- Pressure to sign quickly: A release or consent presented with a short deadline and no supporting figures.
None of these proves misconduct by itself. Each is a reason to ask questions, request records, and get independent advice.
What Is Often Mistaken for Disloyalty
Frustration with an estate's pace or outcome is common, and some ordinary lawyer conduct can look suspicious from the outside.
- Declining to answer your legal questions: The estate's lawyer cannot act as your advisor without creating a conflict. A polite refusal to advise you is often the lawyer following the rules.
- Slow progress: New York estates take time. Court processing, locating heirs, selling real property, and the creditor claims period all add months. Our sample NYC probate timeline shows the usual stages.
- Cordial dealings with opposing counsel: Professional courtesy between lawyers on opposite sides is normal and usually makes cases move faster.
- Your own lawyer recommending settlement: If you have hired counsel in an estate dispute and that lawyer recommends settling, it usually reflects a judgment about litigation risk and cost. You can ask the lawyer to explain the reasoning in writing and you can get a second opinion.
- Refusing to make an argument: A lawyer may decline to assert a claim that has no legal basis. New York courts can sanction frivolous conduct under 22 NYCRR Part 130.
The New York Conflict-of-Interest Rules, Stated Accurately
Lawyers in New York are governed by the Rules of Professional Conduct, codified at 22 NYCRR Part 1200. The full text is available through the New York State Unified Court System. The rules most relevant to a suspicion that a lawyer is working for the other side are these:
- Rule 1.7 (current clients): A lawyer may not represent a client if a reasonable lawyer would conclude that the representation will involve differing interests, or that there is a significant risk the lawyer's judgment will be adversely affected by the lawyer's own interests. Under Rule 1.7(b), the lawyer may still proceed if the lawyer reasonably believes they can provide competent and diligent representation to each affected client, the representation is not prohibited by law, and each affected client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing. One conflict cannot be waived: under Rule 1.7(b)(3), a lawyer may not represent one client asserting a claim against another client the lawyer represents in the same litigation or proceeding before a tribunal.
- Rule 1.8(f) (third-party payment): A lawyer may accept payment for representing a client from someone other than the client only if the client gives informed consent, the payment does not interfere with the lawyer's independent judgment or the client-lawyer relationship, and client confidences are protected. In estate disputes, this comes up when a family member pays the legal fees of a beneficiary or fiduciary.
- Rule 1.9 (former clients): A lawyer who represented a client in a matter may not later represent another person in the same or a substantially related matter where that person's interests are materially adverse to the former client, unless the former client gives informed consent, confirmed in writing. The lawyer also may not use the former client's confidential information to that client's disadvantage, with limited exceptions.
- Rule 1.6 (confidentiality): A lawyer may not knowingly reveal or use a client's confidential information without consent, except in narrow circumstances the rule describes.
Joint representation is not automatically improper. A lawyer may, for example, represent co-executors together, or represent an executor who is also a beneficiary. What matters is whether the clients' interests actually conflict and, if so, whether the required written consents were obtained.
When the Drafting Attorney Is Named Executor or Receives a Gift
Two New York rules address lawyers who benefit under a will they drafted:
- SCPA 2307-a: If a testator names the attorney who drafted the will, or someone affiliated with that attorney, as executor, the testator must sign a written acknowledgment of specific disclosures. Without a compliant acknowledgment, the attorney-executor's commissions are generally limited to one half of the statutory amount.
- Putnam inquiry: Under longstanding New York case law (Matter of Putnam), a gift in a will to the attorney who drafted it raises an inference of undue influence. The Surrogate's Court may require the attorney to explain the gift. If you are considering a challenge on this basis, see our page on will contests.
What Beneficiaries Can Do in Surrogate's Court
Most problems that beneficiaries attribute to the estate's lawyer are resolved by holding the fiduciary accountable. The Surrogate's Court Procedure Act gives interested persons several tools:
- Ask for information informally: Write to the executor, with a copy to the estate's lawyer, requesting an inventory of assets and a list of expenses paid, including legal fees. Keep a copy of the request.
- Petition for information or turnover: SCPA 2102 allows an interested person to petition the court to require a fiduciary to provide information about the estate or to pay or deliver money or property.
- Compel an accounting: Under SCPA 2205, the court can order the fiduciary to file a formal account of everything received, spent, and distributed. Our accountings page explains the process.
- Object to the account: Once an account is filed, beneficiaries can file objections to specific transactions, including fees paid to the estate's lawyer.
- Challenge attorney fees: Under SCPA 2110, the court can fix and determine the compensation of the attorney for the estate. Fees are evaluated for reasonableness, and the court can direct that excess fees be refunded.
- Seek removal of the fiduciary: SCPA 711 and 719 allow the court to suspend, modify, or revoke letters for misconduct such as wasting assets, failing to account, or self-dealing. See our page on removing an executor or administrator.
- Bring a breach of fiduciary duty claim: A fiduciary who causes a loss to the estate can be surcharged, meaning ordered to repay it. See breach of fiduciary duty and, for trusts, breach of trust and beneficiaries' rights to trust information.
The most direct protection is to retain your own lawyer. Your lawyer owes duties to you, can review documents before you sign them, and can raise these issues with the court.
Remedies Against a Lawyer in New York
If your concern is with a lawyer's own conduct, New York has specific procedures. Some are open only to the lawyer's clients, so it matters whether you hired the lawyer or are a beneficiary dealing with the estate's lawyer.
- Attorney Grievance Committees: Complaints about ethical violations go to the Attorney Grievance Committee for the Appellate Division Department where the lawyer practices. There are four Departments, and procedures are set out in 22 NYCRR Part 1240. Anyone, including a non-client, can file a complaint. Possible outcomes range from dismissal to private admonition, public censure, suspension, or disbarment. A grievance does not recover money for you.
- Fee dispute arbitration (Part 137): Clients in civil matters can arbitrate many fee disputes with their own lawyer under 22 NYCRR Part 137. The program generally covers disputes between $1,000 and $50,000, with exceptions. Details are on the court system's fee dispute page. If you are a beneficiary objecting to estate counsel's fees paid from estate funds, the usual route is SCPA 2110 in Surrogate's Court.
- Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection: If a New York lawyer stole or misappropriated money or property in the practice of law, the Lawyers' Fund for Client Protection may reimburse losses. It does not cover fee disputes or malpractice.
- Judiciary Law § 487: An attorney who is guilty of deceit or collusion, or consents to deceit or collusion, with intent to deceive the court or any party, is guilty of a misdemeanor and may be liable for treble damages in a civil action. This statute addresses the conduct people mean when they say a lawyer is "in cahoots" with the other side, and it requires proof of intent to deceive.
- Legal malpractice: A malpractice claim requires proof that the lawyer failed to use ordinary skill and knowledge, and that this failure caused actual, measurable damages. The limitations period is generally three years under CPLR 214(6), and it may be tolled while the lawyer continues to represent you on the same matter. New York applies a strict privity rule: beneficiaries generally cannot sue the executor's lawyer or the lawyer who drafted the will for malpractice. Under Estate of Schneider v. Finmann (2010), the estate's personal representative may bring an estate-planning malpractice claim on behalf of the estate.
Changing Your Own Lawyer
If you hired a lawyer to represent you in an estate dispute and you have lost confidence in that lawyer, you can change counsel. In a pending court proceeding, CPLR 321(b) provides two methods. The first is a consent to change attorney, signed by the outgoing lawyer and signed and acknowledged by you, then filed with the court. The second, if the outgoing lawyer will not sign, is a court order on motion.
Your former lawyer may assert a lien for unpaid fees. A charging lien under Judiciary Law § 475 attaches to the proceeds of your claim. A retaining lien, recognized under common law, can allow a lawyer to hold your file until fees are paid or secured. Courts often resolve file disputes by setting the fee amount or requiring security so the file can be turned over. Your new lawyer can usually work this out without delaying the case for long.
A Practical Way to Sort Out Your Concern
- Identify whose lawyer it is: If the lawyer represents the executor or administrator, your remedy is usually against the fiduciary in Surrogate's Court.
- Write down specifics: Note dates, amounts, documents, and what was said. Specific facts are what courts and grievance committees act on.
- Request records in writing: Ask for an inventory, bank statements, and invoices for legal fees charged to the estate.
- Get independent advice: Have a lawyer who represents you review the facts before you sign anything or take action.
- Choose the right forum: Use Surrogate's Court for accountings, fee review, and fiduciary removal. Use the Attorney Grievance Committee for ethical violations. Use the Lawyers' Fund for stolen funds.
Talk to a New York Estate Litigation Lawyer
If you are a beneficiary and suspect that an estate is being mishandled, or you are unsure whether the estate's lawyer has a conflict, we can review your situation and explain your options in Surrogate's Court. For related issues, see our pages on inheritance disputes and beneficiaries' right to a copy of the will. Contact our office to schedule a consultation.
Written by Albert Goodwin, Esq., an attorney whose practice focuses on New York estate, probate, and trust matters in Surrogate's Court. This page provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice for any specific situation.