Mr. Goodwin is everything you want in an attorney: professional, honest, thorough, and genuinely caring. He always explains things clearly, so I understood exactly what was happening and what to expect next. His attention to detail and persistence really stood out. Looking back, I feel lucky to have found him. He guided me through the whole process expertly, and I deeply appreciate all his hard work. Would definitely recommend him to anyone needing legal help.
Call Today:
212-233-1233
Breach of Trust by a Trustee in New York: A Beneficiary's Guide to Remedies
If you are the beneficiary of a New York trust and you suspect your trustee has mismanaged assets, engaged in self-dealing, made improper distributions, or hidden information from you, you have powerful remedies under New York law. This page focuses specifically on breach of trust by a trustee of an estate or living trust and the steps a beneficiary can take in the Surrogate's Court to recover losses, remove the wrongdoer, and protect the trust corpus.
If a trustee has breached your trust, the Law Offices of Albert Goodwin can help. We handle estate and trust litigation in the Surrogate's Courts of New York County, Kings County (Brooklyn), Queens County, and surrounding jurisdictions. Call 212-233-1233 or email [email protected].
Note: This page addresses breaches by trustees and estate fiduciaries specifically. For breaches in business, corporate, or partnership relationships, see our breach of fiduciary duty and breach of fiduciary duty attorney pages, and our definition of fiduciary duty overview.
What duties does a New York trustee owe?
A trustee of a New York trust is held to the highest standard the law imposes. The core duties are codified in the Estates, Powers and Trusts Law (EPTL) and the common law:
- Duty of loyalty. The trustee must administer the trust solely in the interest of the beneficiaries. Self-dealing — buying trust property, lending trust funds to oneself, or favoring one's own interests — is prohibited.
- Duty of prudent investment. Under the New York Prudent Investor Act (EPTL 11-2.3), a trustee must invest and manage trust assets as a prudent investor would, considering the purposes, terms, and distribution requirements of the trust, and must diversify investments unless the trustee reasonably determines it is in the interests of the beneficiaries not to do so.
- Duty to account. A trustee must keep clear records and render an accounting of all receipts, disbursements, and assets. Beneficiaries have a right to this information.
- Duty of impartiality. When there are multiple beneficiaries (for example, an income beneficiary and a remainderman), the trustee must act impartially among them.
- Duty of care. The trustee must administer the trust with the care, skill, and caution a reasonably prudent person would use.
The "no further inquiry" rule and self-dealing
New York applies the strict "no further inquiry" rule to self-dealing transactions. When a trustee deals with trust property for his or her own account, the transaction is voidable at the option of the beneficiary regardless of whether the price was fair or even favorable to the trust. The court will not inquire into the good faith or fairness of the deal — the conflict alone is enough. The Court of Appeals articulated this principle in Birnbaum v. Birnbaum, 73 N.Y.2d 461 (1989), holding that a fiduciary owes a duty of "undivided and undiluted loyalty" and may not place itself in a position where its interests conflict with those of the beneficiaries. This is why a trustee cannot sell trust assets to himself, his spouse, or his own business even at market value without proper authorization.
What counts as a breach of trust?
Common breaches by New York trustees include:
- Self-dealing or commingling trust funds with personal accounts
- Using trust assets for the trustee's personal benefit
- Making imprudent, speculative, or undiversified investments that cause losses
- Failing to invest cash that should be earning a return
- Paying improper or excessive fees to the trustee or to friends and relatives
- Refusing to provide an accounting or to share information with beneficiaries
- Favoring one beneficiary over another in violation of the duty of impartiality
- Failing to make required distributions of income or principal
- Hiding or failing to collect estate or trust assets
Beneficiary remedies in the Surrogate's Court
New York beneficiaries are not limited to suing for money damages. The Surrogate's Court Procedure Act (SCPA) provides a toolkit of remedies, and a beneficiary often pursues several at once.
1. Compel an accounting
Under SCPA 2205, an interested party can petition the Surrogate's Court to compel a fiduciary to account. The accounting forces the trustee to disclose, under oath, everything that came into the trust, everything that went out, and what remains. The accounting is frequently the discovery vehicle that exposes the breach. Beneficiaries may then file objections to the account, framing the specific transactions they challenge.
2. Surcharge the trustee
If the court sustains objections, it can surcharge the trustee — meaning it orders the trustee to repay the trust from the trustee's own pocket for losses caused by the breach, plus lost investment returns and, in some cases, interest. A trustee who profited from self-dealing may also be required to disgorge those profits to the trust.
3. Remove the trustee
Under SCPA 711, the court may suspend, modify, or revoke a fiduciary's letters and remove a trustee for grounds including wasting or improperly applying trust assets, dishonesty, drunkenness, improvidence, or unfitness. Under SCPA 719, the court may remove a fiduciary without a hearing in certain situations, such as where the fiduciary has failed to obey a court order, has mingled trust funds with personal funds, or has refused to account. For more on removing a fiduciary, see our pages on administrator removal and estate and trust accountings.
4. Deny or reduce commissions
A trustee who breaches the trust may forfeit some or all of the statutory commissions otherwise allowed under SCPA 2309. Courts have discretion to deny commissions where the trustee's misconduct caused loss to the trust.
5. Injunctive relief
Where trust assets are at immediate risk, a beneficiary may seek a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction to freeze accounts or block a pending transaction while the litigation proceeds.
What evidence proves a breach of trust?
Building a successful objection or surcharge claim usually requires:
- The trust instrument and any amendments, which define the trustee's authority and the beneficiaries' interests
- Bank, brokerage, and investment statements showing how trust assets were handled
- The trustee's accounting (or the absence of one)
- Records of distributions, fees, and expenses
- Appraisals showing the value of property at the time of any sale
- Correspondence reflecting the trustee's decisions and disclosures (or non-disclosures)
Much of this is obtained through the accounting proceeding and through discovery under the CPLR, which governs disclosure in Surrogate's Court matters (SCPA 102 incorporates the CPLR where the SCPA is silent).
Statute of limitations
The time limit to sue depends on the nature of the claim. A breach of fiduciary duty claim seeking money damages is generally governed by a three-year statute (CPLR 214) when only monetary relief is sought, while an equitable claim — such as one seeking removal or an accounting — is generally subject to a six-year period (CPLR 213). Importantly, the limitations period for a beneficiary's claim against a trustee often does not begin to run until the trust relationship is openly repudiated by the trustee or the trust terminates and the trustee accounts. Because the analysis is fact-specific and missing a deadline can bar recovery entirely, you should consult an attorney promptly.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue a trustee personally?
Yes. A surcharge holds the trustee personally liable to restore losses caused by the breach. The trustee pays from personal assets, not from the trust.
What if the trustee is also a beneficiary?
A trustee who is also a beneficiary still owes the full fiduciary duties to the other beneficiaries. Being a co-beneficiary is not a defense to self-dealing or to favoring one's own share.
The trustee won't give me any information. What can I do?
Beneficiaries have a right to information about the trust. If the trustee refuses, you can petition to compel an accounting under SCPA 2205 and, in serious cases, seek removal under SCPA 719. See our page on beneficiaries' rights to trust information.
Will I have to pay for the litigation out of my own pocket?
In some cases the court may award legal fees and costs out of the trust or charge them to the trustee personally, particularly where the trustee's misconduct made the litigation necessary. Fee arrangements vary, and you should discuss the specifics with counsel.
How long does a Surrogate's Court breach case take?
Contested accounting and removal proceedings can take from several months to a few years depending on the complexity of the assets, the volume of objections, and whether the case settles or proceeds to trial.
Speak with a New York trust litigation attorney
If a trustee has mismanaged your inheritance, engaged in self-dealing, or refused to account, prompt action protects both the trust assets and your rights. The Law Offices of Albert Goodwin represents beneficiaries in trust and estate disputes in the Surrogate's Courts of New York City, Brooklyn, and Queens. Call 212-233-1233 or email [email protected] to discuss your situation.
This page provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice. Outcomes depend on the specific facts of each case.
About the Author
Albert Goodwin Esq. is a licensed New York attorney with over 18 years of courtroom experience. His extensive knowledge and expertise make him well-qualified to write authoritative articles on a wide range of legal topics. He can be reached at 212-233-1233 or [email protected].
