Yes. In New York you can make, sign, and change a will without telling your husband. He does not have to sign it, approve it, or be present. No court or agency notifies him while you are alive.
Two limits apply. First, the privacy lasts only during your lifetime. When the will is offered for probate, your husband will be formally notified and can read it. Second, your will cannot take away certain rights New York gives a surviving spouse, chiefly the elective share. The rest of this page explains how to sign and store a will privately, what your husband learns after your death, and which of his rights your will cannot override.
Under EPTL 3-1.1, any person who is at least 18 years old and of sound mind and memory can make a will. A married woman needs no one's permission. Your husband's consent is not a condition of validity, and he has no power to revoke or amend your will.
The will must reflect your own decisions. A will signed under duress, fraud, or undue influence can be challenged. If you are making a will privately because of pressure at home, your attorney can meet with you alone and document that the plan is yours. For more on challenges, see our page on will contests in New York.
Most of the question "can I do this on my own" comes down to execution. A will that is not signed correctly may be denied probate, and your property would then pass under intestacy rules, which give a surviving husband a large share. EPTL 3-2.1 sets the requirements:
Some practical points for a private signing:
When an attorney supervises the signing, New York courts presume the will was properly executed. That presumption makes later objections harder to sustain, which is one reason to have counsel run the ceremony. Our New York will attorneys handle the drafting and the signing.
A New York will is not filed anywhere or registered while you are alive. Nobody receives a copy unless you give one out. The main risk to privacy is physical: where the original is kept and who can find it.
Tell one trusted person, usually your named executor, where the original is. A will no one can find does not help you.
You can amend your will with a codicil or replace it with a new will at any time, again without telling your husband. A codicil must be signed with the same formalities as a will under EPTL 3-2.1. Crossing out lines or writing notes on the original is not an effective way to amend it and may cause disputes.
Secrecy in a will is temporary. After your death, the original must be filed with the Surrogate's Court to be probated. Once filed, the will and the probate petition become part of the court record.
Your husband is your distributee, meaning a person who would inherit if you had no will (EPTL 4-1.1). Under SCPA 1403, every distributee must be served with a citation in the probate proceeding unless he signs a waiver and consent. Either way, he will be told that the will is being offered for probate and can obtain a copy. He also has the right to file objections, and before objecting he can ask to examine the attesting witnesses and the attorney who supervised the signing.
If he suspects a will exists but no one files it, he can bring a proceeding to compel its production (SCPA 1401). In practice, you should plan on your husband reading your will after your death. Write it with that in mind, and keep any personal explanations factual and brief.
Assets that pass outside probate, such as some trusts and beneficiary-designated accounts, are not described in the will. They can still count toward his elective share, as explained below. For background on what is public, see are trusts public record? and are beneficiaries entitled to a copy of the will? For how long the process usually takes, see our sample NYC probate timeline.
New York is not a community property state, so your husband does not automatically own half of what you acquired during the marriage. Property titled in your sole name is yours to leave by will. New York protects surviving spouses in a different way, through the rights below.
A surviving husband can elect to take the greater of:
If your net estate is less than $50,000, he can take the entire net estate.
The net estate is your probate estate after debts, administration expenses, and reasonable funeral expenses. Estate taxes are not deducted. To that figure the court adds certain non-probate transfers called testamentary substitutes. These include joint bank accounts, payable-on-death and transfer-on-death accounts, Totten trust accounts, property in a revocable trust, many retirement benefits, and gifts made within one year of death above the federal annual exclusion amount. Life insurance proceeds are not a testamentary substitute under New York law. You cannot avoid the elective share simply by moving money out of your will and into these other arrangements.
Whatever your husband receives under the will, or through a testamentary substitute that passes to him, is credited against his elective share. He collects only the difference, and that difference is paid proportionally by the other beneficiaries of the will and the substitutes.
Assume you die with:
The net estate for elective-share purposes is $600,000 plus $150,000, or $750,000. One-third is $250,000. Your will left your husband $50,000, so if he files a right of election he receives an additional $200,000. That $200,000 is taken ratably from your sister's share of the probate estate and the POD account. Leaving him a small gift in the will does not prevent the election. It only reduces what must be paid to satisfy it.
Your husband must serve a written notice of election on your executor and file it with the Surrogate's Court within six months after letters testamentary or letters of administration are issued. The election can never be made more than two years after your death. If he misses the deadline, the right is generally lost, although the court can extend the time in limited circumstances if he applies before the deadline expires. See letters testamentary for when that clock starts.
A spouse can give up the elective share, and the waiver does not have to be part of a prenuptial agreement. Under EPTL 5-1.1-A(e), a waiver can be signed before or during the marriage. It must be in writing, signed by the spouse giving up the right, and acknowledged in the form required to record a deed, which in practice means before a notary with a proper acknowledgment. A postnuptial agreement or a separation agreement can include this waiver. A waiver cannot be signed in secret, because your husband must sign it himself. Each spouse should have separate counsel.
Federal law adds a separate limit. Under ERISA, many employer plans, including most 401(k) plans, must pay a married participant's account to the surviving spouse unless the spouse has consented in writing to a different beneficiary, with that consent witnessed by a notary or plan representative. If you want a 401(k) to go to someone other than your husband, he will have to sign. IRAs are not governed by this rule, but they can still count toward the New York elective share.
A surviving spouse is entitled to certain property set off before the estate is distributed, and it is in addition to anything left to him by will. The categories include household furniture, appliances, and similar items up to $20,000; one motor vehicle up to $25,000; and up to $25,000 in money or other personal property, along with other items listed in the statute. Your will cannot override these amounts. If you plan to leave specific household contents or a car to someone else, discuss how this exemption affects the plan.
New York disqualifies a surviving spouse from taking an elective share, an intestate share, or exempt property in specific situations. Among them:
Disqualification is decided by the Surrogate's Court after your death, and the person raising it, usually your executor or another beneficiary, carries the burden of proof. You will not be there to testify, so the evidence has to exist on paper. If abandonment or non-support applies to your situation, keep records while you can:
Store these records with your attorney or with the original will so your executor can find them. An attorney can also include a factual statement in the estate file, and the will can name an executor who is prepared to pursue the claim.
This is often the situation behind a private will, and the timing matters.
If a divorce is pending, sign the new will now so that an old will naming your husband is not the operative document if you die during the case. Coordinate every change to accounts, deeds, and beneficiary forms with your matrimonial attorney first.
No. Only you and two attesting witnesses sign. Your husband should not serve as a witness. His signature is needed only for a waiver of his elective share or for federal spousal consent on certain retirement plans.
Not while you are alive, unless he finds the document or you tell him. After your death he will be served with a citation in the probate proceeding (or asked to sign a waiver and consent) under SCPA 1403, and he can obtain a copy of the will.
You can write a will that leaves him nothing, and it is valid. He can still claim his elective share under EPTL 5-1.1-A and exempt property under EPTL 5-3.1, unless he has waived those rights in a signed and acknowledged writing or is disqualified under EPTL 5-1.2.
Yes. A codicil or a new will requires the same signing formalities as the original, and no notice to your spouse. If a divorce action is pending, check with your matrimonial attorney before moving any assets to match the new plan.
Generally, no. Revocable trusts, joint accounts, POD and TOD accounts, and similar arrangements are testamentary substitutes that are added back into the net estate. For broader planning, see our pages on trusts in New York and avoiding probate in New York.
Under New York intestacy rules (EPTL 4-1.1), a surviving husband receives the entire estate if you have no children, or $50,000 plus half of the rest if you do. A valid will is the only way to direct property elsewhere, within the limits described above.
We draft New York wills, supervise private signings with independent witnesses, prepare self-proving affidavits, hold original wills in safekeeping, and review whether an elective share claim or a disqualification defense is likely in your situation. We also work with matrimonial counsel when a divorce is pending.
The Law Offices of Albert Goodwin has offices in New York City, Brooklyn, and Queens. Call 212-233-1233 or email [email protected] to schedule a confidential consultation. You can also read more about our will drafting services or our Brooklyn estate practice.
This page provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice for your situation. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.