New York has two separate guardianship laws for adults. The one that fits your brother or sister depends on why he or she needs help. Families usually come to us in one of two situations. The first is a parent who has died or is aging, leaving behind a brother with autism, Down syndrome, cerebral palsy or another lifelong disability. The second is an adult sibling who was managing on his own until dementia, a stroke, a brain injury, mental illness or addiction made it unsafe. These situations go to different courts, use different forms and apply different legal standards.
This guide starts with that choice. It then covers the court steps, the sibling situations that come up most often, the alternatives a judge will expect you to have considered, and what the process costs.
SCPA Article 17-A covers adults with an intellectual or developmental disability. These cases are heard in Surrogate's Court. MHL Article 81 covers adults of any background whose functional limitations put them at risk of harm. These cases are usually heard in Supreme Court. Many families file under the wrong article, lose time, and then have to start over.
| Question | SCPA Article 17-A | MHL Article 81 |
|---|---|---|
| Who it is for | Adults (or people turning 18) with an intellectual disability or a developmental disability such as autism, cerebral palsy, epilepsy or certain neurological impairments, generally present since childhood (SCPA 1750, 1750-a) | Adults who cannot manage personal needs or property and do not understand that inability, from any cause: dementia, stroke, traumatic brain injury, serious mental illness, substance use or physical decline (MHL 81.02) |
| Court | Surrogate's Court in the county where your sibling lives | Supreme Court in the county where your sibling lives |
| Medical proof | Certifications from two physicians, or one physician and one licensed psychologist, confirming the disability and that guardianship is in the person's best interest | Evidence of functional limitations and likelihood of harm, proven by clear and convincing evidence; usually medical records, a physician affirmation and testimony |
| Hearing | Required in most cases, but the court may dispense with it when the parents petition or consent (SCPA 1754) | Required, with a court evaluator's investigation and report |
| Scope of powers | Historically broad. The guardian of the person makes most personal and health decisions, though judges increasingly look at what the person can do for himself | Limited to the specific powers the court finds necessary (MHL 81.02(a), 81.16) |
| Successor planning | Parents can name a standby guardian, often a sibling, who steps in when the parent dies or can no longer serve (SCPA 1757) | Successor guardians can be requested, but most sibling petitions are new filings |
| Reporting | Annual accounts for property guardians; reporting requirements for guardians of the person vary by court | Initial report within 90 days and annual reports reviewed by a court examiner (MHL 81.30–81.32) |
A quick test: if your brother's disability began before adulthood and is expected to last for life, start with 17-A. If he was an independent adult who later lost capacity, Article 81 applies. A diagnosis of mental illness alone, such as schizophrenia or bipolar disorder, does not qualify for 17-A. Some people fit both statutes. For example, an adult with autism who has substantial assets or a pending lawsuit may be better served by an Article 81 order with specific property powers.
Many parents obtain 17-A guardianship when their child turns 18. If the parent's decree named you as standby guardian or alternate standby guardian, you can assume the role right away when the parent dies, becomes incapacitated or renounces. You must then ask the Surrogate's Court to confirm your appointment, generally within 60 days of taking over (SCPA 1757). Do not wait. Without a confirmed decree, banks, agencies and medical providers may refuse to deal with you.
If the decree did not name a standby, or the named standby cannot serve, you file a new 17-A petition as successor guardian. You will need fresh medical certifications if the existing ones are old.
Some parents handled everything informally for decades. When they die, the adult child with a disability may have no one with legal authority to sign medical consents, deal with Social Security, or manage an inheritance. A sibling can file a 17-A petition. You will need:
The court may appoint a guardian ad litem or notify Mental Hygiene Legal Service (MHLS) to protect your sibling's interests. Your sibling has the right to appear and to object.
A 17-A guardian makes health care decisions under SCPA 1750-b. That section sets specific procedures, including notice and medical confirmation, before a guardian can decline life-sustaining treatment. If you were named in a parent's decree, read it closely. Some decrees limit the guardian's medical authority.
Under MHL 81.02(b), the court must find by clear and convincing evidence that your sibling is likely to suffer harm because he cannot provide for personal needs or manage property, and he cannot adequately understand and appreciate the consequences of that inability. Both parts must be proven. A diagnosis is not enough. The court looks at daily functioning: paying bills, taking medication, keeping housing, shopping, banking and getting around (MHL 81.03(h)). It also weighs your sibling's own wishes and values (MHL 81.02(c)).
Yes. MHL 81.06 allows a petition by a presumptive distributee, which usually includes a brother or sister, or by any person concerned with the welfare of the person alleged to be incapacitated. The person you are asking the court to protect is called the AIP. Being allowed to file is different from being appointed. Under MHL 81.19, the court considers whom the AIP would choose, any prior nomination in a power of attorney or health care proxy, the candidate's relationship with the AIP, and any conflicts of interest.
If your brother's accounts are being drained or a medical decision cannot wait, you can ask the court to appoint a temporary guardian under MHL 81.23 when you file. The court can also issue a temporary restraining order freezing accounts or stopping a property transfer. The proof must show immediate danger, not general concern.
The examples below are composites of situations families bring to us. They are illustrations, not case results, and they do not predict how any court will rule.
A mother held 17-A guardianship of her adult son with autism and named her daughter as standby guardian. After the mother's death, the daughter takes over and files for confirmation within the 60-day window. The harder issues are often financial. If the mother's will left the son money outright, that inheritance could cost him SSI and Medicaid. The family may need a court-approved first-party supplemental needs trust. If the will left his share in a third-party supplemental needs trust, his benefits are usually protected. Parents still planning should read our page on wills for parents in New York and make sure the will and the 17-A standby designation work together.
Families often expect guardianship to force a sibling into treatment. It usually cannot. An Article 81 guardian may not consent to a voluntary admission to a psychiatric facility on the person's behalf (MHL 81.22(b)). Involuntary psychiatric admission runs through MHL Article 9, which requires physician certifications or emergency findings. Court-ordered outpatient treatment runs through Kendra's Law (MHL 9.60). An adult sibling is one of the people allowed to request an assisted outpatient treatment petition. Guardianship can still help with housing, benefits and money when the illness is causing her to lose an apartment or be exploited. Courts look hard at these petitions because periods of mental illness can come and go.
An older brother with early dementia has a new "friend" who has added herself to his bank accounts, or a relative is using a power of attorney to pay her own bills. The petition should lay out the transactions with bank records. You may ask the court to appoint a temporary guardian, freeze accounts, and give the guardian power to recover transferred assets under MHL 81.21 and 81.29. A guardian can ask the court to revoke a power of attorney or health care proxy. See our pages on stopping an agent who is abusing a power of attorney and compelling an accounting.
When two or three siblings all want control, or one objects to another, the court evaluator usually interviews each of them. The judge may appoint one sibling as guardian of the person and another as guardian of the property, name co-guardians, or appoint an independent professional guardian if the family conflict itself is harming the AIP. A sibling who lives with the AIP, shares bank accounts with him, or stands to inherit from him will be asked about it. Disclose these facts in the petition. Hiding them hurts your credibility more than the facts themselves.
A spouse does not automatically outrank a sibling under Article 81, but the court gives weight to the marriage and to the AIP's wishes. If the spouse is meeting the AIP's needs, the court will likely find that guardianship is unnecessary. If the spouse is the source of neglect or exploitation, the evidence must show that directly.
An out-of-state brother or sister can petition and can be appointed. The court will want to know how you will manage day-to-day care from a distance and who will visit. If your sibling already lives in another state, that state usually has jurisdiction. MHL Article 83, New York's version of the Uniform Adult Guardianship and Protective Proceedings Jurisdiction Act, decides which state hears the case and how a guardianship is transferred.
Guardianship takes away legal rights, so New York courts deny Article 81 petitions when less restrictive tools already protect the person (MHL 81.02(a)(2)). The petition must address these alternatives. If your sibling still has the capacity to sign documents, these options are often faster and cheaper:
If your brother lacks capacity to sign any of these, or if an existing agent is misusing authority, guardianship may be the only route.
Yes, for Article 81. MHL 81.39 requires guardians to complete a court-approved training program, usually within a set period after appointment, unless the court waives it. The course covers fiduciary duties, reporting, and the person's rights. Article 17-A does not have the same statutory training requirement, though some Surrogate's Courts provide guardian materials.
An Article 81 guardian is entitled to compensation under MHL 81.28, generally calculated like executor commissions under SCPA 2307 and paid from your sibling's funds. The court can adjust it. Many family guardians waive compensation, especially when the estate is small or benefits must be protected. Keep receipts. You can be reimbursed for legitimate expenses with court approval.
A guardian with authority to choose the place of abode can move your sibling, but MHL 81.22 directs the guardian to favor the least restrictive setting and to consult the person's wishes. Moving him to another state usually needs court permission and may require transferring the guardianship under MHL Article 83. Never move a ward out of state without checking the order.
Guardianship does not change eligibility. The guardian's choices can. SSI has a strict resource limit, and an inheritance, back pay or lawsuit settlement can end benefits if it is not placed in a supplemental needs trust or ABLE account. An Article 81 guardian can ask the court for authority to create one (MHL 81.21). Report your appointment to Social Security and the Medicaid office, and ask SSA whether you also need to apply as representative payee.
He has the right to object, to have a lawyer, and to demand a jury in an Article 81 case. The court will not appoint a guardian because the family disagrees with his lifestyle. You must show functional incapacity and likely harm. In a 17-A case, his objection usually leads the court to hold a hearing.
You are a fiduciary. You are not personally liable for your sibling's debts. You can be held personally responsible for misusing funds, commingling his money with yours, or failing to file required reports. The bond protects your sibling if that happens, and the surety can seek repayment from you. See our page on breach of fiduciary duty.
Yes. Your sibling, you, or any interested person can ask the court to modify the guardian's powers or discharge the guardian when circumstances change (MHL 81.36). A guardian who is not doing the job can be removed (MHL 81.35). See our page on removing a court-appointed fiduciary. Under 17-A, a modification or discharge petition goes to the Surrogate's Court that issued the decree.
Costs depend on which statute applies, whether anyone objects, and how much property is involved.
An uncontested 17-A petition with parental consent can be decided in a few weeks to a few months, depending on the county's backlog. An uncontested Article 81 case often takes two to three months from filing to commission. Contested Article 81 cases, especially with a jury demand or competing siblings, can take six months or longer. Temporary guardianship can be granted within days when the danger is immediate.
Article 81 cases in New York County, Kings, Queens, Bronx and Richmond are handled by Supreme Court justices assigned to guardianship matters, with court examiners reviewing annual reports. Nassau, Suffolk and Westchester also have judges who handle guardianship regularly. Each court has its own scheduling habits and preferred proposed-order formats. Surrogate's Court practice on 17-A varies by county as well, including how often hearings are waived and what the court asks of a guardian of the person after appointment. If you live in Brooklyn, see our page on Brooklyn estate matters.
Official forms and plain-language guides are available from the New York State Unified Court System's CourtHelp site. The full text of the Mental Hygiene Law and the Surrogate's Court Procedure Act is available on the New York State Senate website.
In most cases, you file under SCPA Article 17-A in the Surrogate's Court of the county where he lives. You will need certifications from two qualified professionals. If a parent already holds 17-A guardianship and named you as standby, you take over when the parent can no longer serve and then seek confirmation within 60 days.
Mental illness alone does not qualify for 17-A, so the route is Article 81 in Supreme Court. You must prove functional limitations and likely harm. Guardianship cannot force psychiatric admission. For treatment, look at Kendra's Law and MHL Article 9.
If a parent held 17-A guardianship and named a standby, that person steps in. If not, someone must petition. Check how the parents' wills left property to him. A direct inheritance can affect SSI and Medicaid unless it passes through a supplemental needs trust.
Article 81 court fees start at $305 for the index number and RJI, plus the court evaluator, any appointed counsel, a bond premium and attorney's fees. Many of these come from your sibling's assets if the petition is granted. 17-A costs are usually lower.
A few weeks to a few months for an uncontested 17-A case, about two to three months for an uncontested Article 81 case, and longer if anyone objects.
Yes, if the court finds you suitable and you have a workable plan for her care. Expect questions about who will be present locally.
The first decision, 17-A or Article 81, shapes everything that follows. So do the related questions about benefits, trusts and the parents' estate plan. Attorney Albert Goodwin handles guardianship petitions and related estate matters in New York City, Long Island and Westchester. To discuss whether guardianship or a less restrictive option fits your brother or sister, call (212) 233-1233 or (516) 777-0647.
This page provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Outcomes depend on the facts of each case.