Mr. Goodwin is everything you want in an attorney: professional, honest, thorough, and genuinely caring. He always explains things clearly, so I understood exactly what was happening and what to expect next. His attention to detail and persistence really stood out. Looking back, I feel lucky to have found him. He guided me through the whole process expertly, and I deeply appreciate all his hard work. Would definitely recommend him to anyone needing legal help.
Cost of Will Contest in New York
There is no fixed cost for will contests in New York. The total expense depends on case complexity, the value of the estate, attorney fees, expert witness costs, and the time required to complete the proceedings. Most attorneys handling will contest cases bill by the hour rather than offering flat fees.
Typical Investment: Will contest proceedings in New York generally require a retainer deposit of approximately $10,000 to get started, with attorneys billing at rates ranging from $500 to $700 per hour for experienced estate litigation counsel.
This guide explains the primary cost components of will contest proceedings:
Attorney Fees & Retainers
Court Costs & Filing Fees
Expert Witness Fees
Discovery & Investigation
Understanding these costs upfront helps you budget appropriately and make informed decisions about challenging a will in New York. The total investment can vary dramatically based on the strength of your case and the estate's complexity.
Contact Us
Law Offices of Albert Goodwin, PLLC
31 W 34 Str, Suite 7058
New York, NY 10001
31 W 34 Str, Suite 7058
New York, NY 10001
Cost Ranges by Stage of Will Contest
Early Settlement
$5K
Preliminary negotiations, out-of-court settlement
Initial Probe
$5K - $15K
SCPA § 1404 proceeding, limited discovery
Full Discovery
$15K - $40K
Complete discovery process, depositions
Trial
$40K - $50K+
Full trial proceedings, expert witnesses
Important: These ranges include all costs - attorney fees, court expenses, expert witness fees, and discovery costs. Higher-value estates often justify higher litigation expenses.
Consider a Preliminary Probe First
Not sure about a full will contest?
If you're unsure whether to pursue a full will contest, you can start with a preliminary probe that costs significantly less than a complete will contest. This allows you to gather evidence and make an informed decision about whether to proceed.
Cost Range
$5,000 - $10,000
Much less than a full contest
What You Get
Evidence to decide whether a full contest is worthwhile
What the Preliminary Probe Includes:
- Documents from the attorney who drafted the will
- Testimony from the will's drafting attorney
- Testimony from witnesses who signed the will
- Other relevant documents and testimony
Based on the evidence obtained during the probe, you can then make an informed decision about whether to commit to a full will contest or abandon the challenge.
Attorney Fees and Retainer Requirements
Hourly Billing Structure
Most will contest attorneys in New York bill by the hour due to the unpredictable nature of estate litigation. Estate litigation attorneys typically charge $500 to $700 per hour depending on their experience and the complexity of the case.
All time spent on your case is billable, including court appearances, document review, depositions, and communications with opposing counsel. Detailed time records are provided with monthly billing statements to track expenses throughout the litigation.
Initial Retainer Deposit
Attorneys typically require an upfront retainer deposit of approximately $10,000 to begin work on will contest proceedings. This retainer serves as an advance deposit on the lawyer's hourly fees and is held in the attorney's trust account.
The retainer deposit guarantees you have representation and that your attorney will prioritize your case, providing you with dedicated legal counsel throughout the will contest process.
Important Note: The retainer is not the total cost of your case - it's a deposit against future hourly billing. Will contests can be expensive and time-consuming, often requiring multiple retainer deposits throughout the proceedings.
The Four Stages of Will Contest Proceedings
Will contests in New York typically proceed through four distinct stages, and the matter may conclude at any point during this process. Understanding these stages helps you anticipate costs and plan your legal strategy.
1.
Preliminary Negotiations
You receive a waiver and consent from the executor's attorney. If you don't sign, the court will issue a citation directing you to show cause why the court should not grant the petition to probate the will. Cost: Minimal if settled at this stage.
2.
Initial Probe (SCPA § 1404)
Limited discovery covering 3 years prior to will execution and 2 years after (or until death). Includes depositions and document requests. Cost: Four to five figures.
3.
Full Discovery Process
After objections are filed, comprehensive discovery continues with extensive document production and depositions of all relevant parties. Cost: Low to mid-five figures.
4.
Trial
When discovery is complete and you wish to continue, trial proceedings begin with expert witnesses and extensive legal preparation. Cost: Mid to high-five figures.
Expert Witness and Discovery Costs
Expert Witness Fees
Will contests often require expert witnesses to prove lack of capacity, undue influence, or fraud. Medical experts typically charge $500-$1,000 per hour for review and testimony, while handwriting experts charge $300-$600 per hour.
Each expert may require 10-40 hours of work including file review, report preparation, deposition testimony, and trial testimony. Multiple experts are often necessary, particularly in cases involving medical capacity issues or document authenticity questions.
Discovery and Investigation
Will contests require extensive discovery including medical records, financial documents, and witness depositions. Medical records can cost $50-$200 per set, while depositions typically cost $400-$800 per day including court reporter and transcript fees.
Investigation costs may include private investigators ($75-$150 per hour), document analysis, and asset searches. These discovery expenses are separate from attorney fees and can add $5,000-$25,000 to the total case cost.
Court Costs and Additional Expenses
Filing and Court Fees
Court filing fees for will contests in Surrogate's Court are $150 for filing objections to the will. If you demand a jury trial, there is an additional $150 jury demand fee. Service of process fees range from $100-$300 per party served.
If the case proceeds to trial, court reporter costs for trial transcripts and other trial-related expenses can add several thousand dollars to the total cost. Note that there are no motion filing fees in Surrogate's Court.
Document and Administrative Costs
Will contests generate significant paperwork and administrative costs. Document copying, certified copies of court records, and electronic filing fees can accumulate to $500-$2,000 throughout the case.
Travel expenses for attorney court appearances, witness interviews, and depositions may also apply, particularly if the decedent lived outside of New York or had property in multiple jurisdictions.
What Affects Will Contest Costs?
The cost of a will contest varies dramatically based on the strength of your legal grounds and the complexity of the case. Cases with clear evidence of fraud or undue influence may settle quickly for $15,000-$35,000, while complex capacity challenges requiring multiple medical experts can reach $50,000 or more.
The estate's value significantly impacts litigation costs. Higher-value estates justify more extensive litigation efforts, and opposing parties are more likely to fight vigorously when substantial assets are at stake. Estates worth millions may involve legal costs of $50,000 or more.
The number of parties involved also affects expenses. Will contests involving multiple heirs, beneficiaries, or interested parties require more complex litigation strategies, additional service costs, and longer court proceedings. Each additional party potentially means another attorney involved in the case.
The chosen legal grounds for the contest heavily influence costs. Fraud cases requiring handwriting analysis and document authentication tend to be less expensive than lack of capacity cases requiring extensive medical expert testimony and psychiatric evaluations.
Strategic Considerations and Fee Recovery
Before pursuing a will contest, carefully evaluate whether the potential recovery justifies the litigation costs. Calculate your expected inheritance under the challenged will versus what you might receive if successful, then subtract anticipated legal expenses, expert fees, and other costs.
Consider the strength of your legal case before committing to expensive litigation. Will contests are challenging to win and require clear evidence of incapacity, undue influence, fraud, or improper execution. Weak cases can result in total loss of your inheritance plus responsibility for the estate's legal fees.
Timing is crucial in will contest litigation. New York law requires will objections to be filed within specific time limits after probate proceedings begin. Delays can result in loss of your right to contest regardless of the strength of your case.
Settlement negotiations often provide better outcomes than trial. Many will contests settle before trial for a fraction of the potential trial costs. Early mediation or direct negotiation can save tens of thousands in legal expenses while achieving acceptable results for all parties.
If You Win
Successful will contests often result in recovery of some, if not most, of your legal expenses from the estate. Your action is deemed beneficial to the estate, making fee recovery likely.
If You Lose
Unsuccessful will contests require you to pay your own legal fees. Courts may also order you to pay the estate's attorney fees, potentially doubling your financial exposure.
Summary
Will contests in New York involve substantial costs with no guaranteed outcomes. While attorneys typically charge $500 to $700 per hour and require approximately $10,000 retainers to begin, total costs can vary dramatically based on case complexity, estate value, and the strength of your legal grounds.
Understanding these cost factors and honestly evaluating your case's merits helps you make informed decisions about whether to pursue will contest litigation or explore settlement alternatives. Many successful outcomes are achieved through negotiation rather than expensive trial proceedings.
Need Help With Will Contest Costs?
For a consultation about the costs and feasibility of a will contest in your specific situation, contact the Law Offices of Albert Goodwin for experienced guidance.
