A living will is the document in which you say, in advance, what medical treatment you do and do not want if you become unable to speak for yourself. New York has no statute that creates or governs living wills, which makes the drafting more important, not less: the document has to be clear enough to satisfy the evidentiary standard New York courts apply. This page explains what a living will covers, how it differs from a health care proxy, what New York law requires, and what happens if you have neither.
What Is a Living Will?
A living will is a written document that specifies the medical treatment you wish to receive, or refuse, if you become incapacitated and cannot make decisions for yourself. Unlike a last will and testament, which takes effect after death, a living will operates during your lifetime, when terminal illness, permanent unconsciousness or another serious condition leaves you unable to communicate. It typically addresses life-sustaining treatment such as mechanical ventilation, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, artificial nutrition and hydration, pain management and palliative care, organ and tissue donation, and any religious or spiritual considerations that should shape your care. Documenting these choices spares your family from guessing at a moment of crisis and reduces the chance of a dispute among relatives.
Living Wills Under New York Law
New York is unusual. Unlike many states, it has no statute that governs living wills. Instead, the Court of Appeals held in In re Westchester County Medical Center (O’Connor) that a person’s wishes regarding life-sustaining treatment must be proven by clear and convincing evidence. A properly drafted living will supplies exactly that evidence, and New York courts have consistently recognized living wills as valid expressions of a person’s health care preferences, provided the document is properly executed and clearly states what the person intends.
Because there is no statutory template, the wording carries the whole weight. A vague statement of preference may not meet the clear and convincing standard; a specific one will.
Living Will vs. Health Care Proxy in New York
People often confuse the two, but they are distinct documents that do complementary jobs. Under Public Health Law Article 29-C, a health care proxy appoints another person, your agent, to make medical decisions for you if you cannot. New York actively encourages residents to sign one and provides a standard form. A living will appoints no one; it records your own decisions directly. Most people should sign both: the proxy ensures that someone you trust can advocate for your wishes, and the living will provides written evidence of what those wishes are.
| Question | Health care proxy | Living will |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Names an agent to decide for you | States your treatment decisions in advance |
| Statutory basis in New York | Public Health Law Article 29-C, with a state form | None; recognized by the courts under the clear and convincing evidence standard |
| Who speaks for you | Your agent, guided by your known wishes | The document itself, read by providers and your agent |
| Best used | Together with a living will | Together with a health care proxy |
Who Needs a Living Will in New York?
Every adult should consider one, whatever their age or health, because accidents and sudden illness do not wait. Without a living will, your family may be left to guess, and providers may be required to administer treatment you would not have wanted. A living will matters most for people with strong feelings about end-of-life care, those diagnosed with a chronic, progressive or terminal illness, anyone facing major surgery or treatment, people whose religious or philosophical beliefs shape their medical choices, those with specific views on organ donation, and anyone who wants to spare their family a difficult decision or head off a family dispute over their care.
Requirements for a Valid Living Will in New York
With no statutory form, the requirements come from what providers and courts will honor. The document must express your wishes about specific treatments in clear and specific language; vague statements may not meet the clear and convincing evidence standard. It should be signed and dated by you in the presence of two adult witnesses who are not related to you and have no financial interest in your estate. Notarization is not strictly required, but it adds a further layer of authenticity.
You must have the mental capacity to understand the nature and consequences of the document when you sign it, which is one reason to make a living will well before any cognitive decline. And it must be signed voluntarily, free of coercion or undue influence from anyone else.
How We Prepare a Living Will
A living will is more than a form. We start with a conversation about your health care preferences, family situation, religious beliefs and concerns about specific treatments, and draft the document to your circumstances in language designed to satisfy New York’s clear and convincing evidence standard. We coordinate it with your health care proxy, power of attorney, will and any trusts so the documents work together, supervise the signing so the formalities are observed, and advise on storing the original and giving copies to your physician, the hospital, family members and your health care agent. We recommend reviewing the document every three to five years, or after a marriage, divorce, serious diagnosis or death in the family.
Common Questions About Living Wills in New York
-
Can I change or revoke my living will?
Yes. As long as you have mental capacity, you can revoke or amend it at any time, by destroying the document, signing a written revocation, or making a new living will that supersedes the old one.
-
Will my New York living will be recognized in other states?
Recognition of advance directives varies from state to state. If you spend significant time outside New York, there are ways to improve the chance that your wishes are honored wherever you need care.
-
What happens if I do not have a living will?
Medical decisions may then be made under New York’s Family Health Care Decisions Act, which sets a hierarchy of surrogate decision-makers. The Act provides a framework, but the decisions may not match your wishes, and it can lead to disputes among family members.
-
Does my doctor have to follow my living will?
Providers in New York are generally obligated to honor clearly expressed wishes in a properly executed living will. A provider with religious or moral objections is typically required to transfer your care to another provider who will honor your directives.
-
Can a living will address dementia or Alzheimer’s disease?
Yes. A well-drafted living will can include specific provisions for what you want if you develop a progressive cognitive condition, and this is an increasingly important part of advance care planning.
When to Do It
Many people put off a living will because they associate it with old age or serious illness. The best time to sign one is while you are healthy and can think through the choices calmly. Once a medical crisis begins, it may be too late to document your wishes. If you would like to prepare a living will, or a full set of advance directives with a health care proxy and power of attorney, call us at 212-233-1233 or email [email protected].
