Mr. Goodwin is everything you want in an attorney: professional, honest, thorough, and genuinely caring. He always explains things clearly, so I understood exactly what was happening and what to expect next. His attention to detail and persistence really stood out. Looking back, I feel lucky to have found him. He guided me through the whole process expertly, and I deeply appreciate all his hard work. Would definitely recommend him to anyone needing legal help.
Call Today:
212-233-1233
Protecting Children's Inheritance in a Second Marriage in New York
The Specific Problem with Second Marriages
Second marriages create a structural conflict that ordinary estate plans do not solve. When you remarry in New York, your new spouse acquires automatic rights to your estate — the right of election, intestacy rights, and other statutory protections — that can override your intent to provide for children from a prior relationship. Without deliberate planning, the sequence is predictable: the new spouse inherits the bulk of the estate, either outright or through the elective share; when the new spouse later dies, those assets pass under the new spouse’s own plan, frequently to the new spouse’s own children; and your children inherit little or nothing, despite your clear intent to provide for them.
This is not a remote risk. It is one of the most common patterns we see in New York Surrogate’s Court contests. The parent assumed the new spouse would “do the right thing” for the children. The moral commitment often does not survive a decade of new family dynamics, a remarriage of the surviving spouse, or a simple change of heart. The only reliable protection is a legal structure, not a promise.
The New York Elective Share — and Its Clawback
The core obstacle is the surviving spouse’s right of election under EPTL § 5-1.1-A. A surviving spouse may elect to take the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate, regardless of what your will or trust says. You cannot defeat this simply by disinheriting your new spouse in your will.
What catches people by surprise is how broadly the “net estate” is computed. The statute reaches well beyond the probate estate by counting testamentary substitutes, a clawback designed precisely to stop spouses from being cut out through non-probate transfers. Testamentary substitutes include Totten trusts and payable-on-death (POD) bank accounts; joint bank accounts and jointly held property (the decedent’s contributed portion); property held in a revocable (living) trust; retirement accounts and certain pension benefits; gifts made within one year of death (above the annual exclusion) and gifts causa mortis; and transfers with a retained life estate or retained power to revoke.
Because the calculation is so inclusive, moving assets into a revocable trust does not shield them from the elective share; the trust corpus is pulled back into the net estate. This is an important point that distinguishes second-marriage planning from the general benefits of a living trust. For how a revocable trust functions in ordinary planning, see our discussion of the benefits of a living trust; for second-marriage purposes, understand that revocability is exactly what makes it transparent to the elective-share clawback.
The three ways to reduce or eliminate the elective share
The first is a valid prenuptial or postnuptial agreement waiving the right under EPTL § 5-1.1-A(e). The second is disqualification of the surviving spouse (for example, abandonment, failure to support, or an invalid divorce) under EPTL § 5-1.2. The third is to leave the spouse at least the elective-share amount outright and use a QTIP trust to carry the balance to your children: property that passes absolutely to the spouse (including qualifying testamentary substitutes) counts against the share, while an income interest in a trust does not (EPTL § 5-1.1-A(a)(4)).
The QTIP Trust: A Worked New York Example
The Qualified Terminable Interest Property (QTIP) trust is the workhorse of second-marriage planning. It threads the needle: it supports your surviving spouse for life while guaranteeing that the remainder goes to your children rather than the spouse’s heirs. A New York QTIP is created in your will or, if set up during life, in a lifetime trust executed under the formalities of EPTL § 7-1.17, and qualifies for the federal marital deduction under IRC § 2056(b)(7).
The mechanics are straightforward. Your assets fund the QTIP trust at your death. Your surviving spouse must receive all trust income for life, payable at least annually, and may receive principal under a defined standard (for example, health, education, maintenance, and support), but does not own or control the trust corpus and cannot redirect it. At the surviving spouse’s death, whatever remains passes to your children, not the spouse’s beneficiaries.
A simplified worked example. Suppose your estate is $1,500,000 and you have two children from a prior marriage. You leave the entire $1,500,000 to a QTIP trust for your new spouse. One caution first: under current New York law a trust income interest does not count against the elective share; only property passing to the spouse outright reduces it (EPTL § 5-1.1-A(a)(4)). Your spouse could therefore still elect to take one-third of the net estate (here, roughly $500,000) outright, and on election the spouse’s interest in the QTIP is cut off and the trust passes on to your children under its terms. In practice the plan is paired with a prenuptial or postnuptial waiver, or the spouse is left at least the elective-share amount outright (for example, $500,000 outright and $1,000,000 in the QTIP) so that electing gains the spouse nothing.
Assuming the waiver or outright funding is in place, your spouse receives, say, 4% income annually (about $60,000 a year on a $1,500,000 trust) plus principal for genuine needs. When your spouse dies, the remaining principal — perhaps $1,200,000 after years of income distributions — passes to your two children. By contrast, had you left the same $1,500,000 to your spouse outright, your spouse could rewrite their will the following week and leave all $1,500,000 to their own children, defeating your intent entirely.
Tax treatment. Because the spouse holds a qualifying income interest, the QTIP qualifies for the unlimited marital deduction at your death, so no estate tax is due then. The assets are included in your spouse’s estate at the second death, but they still pass to your children under the trust terms. A QTIP election also lets the executor use New York’s separate estate tax thresholds across both deaths with proper planning.
One important New York caution. New York permits a state-only QTIP election, but the rules differ from the federal regime and the state “cliff” can sharply increase the New York estate tax if the taxable estate exceeds roughly 105% of the basic exclusion amount. The election should be modeled, not assumed.
When an Irrevocable Trust Beats a QTIP
The QTIP is the right tool when you want to provide income to your spouse for life. It is the wrong tool in several second-marriage situations, where a lifetime irrevocable trust is better:
| Your goal | Why an irrevocable trust fits better |
|---|---|
| Assets out of reach of the elective share entirely | A properly structured, fully funded irrevocable trust created and funded outside the one-year clawback window, with no retained powers, is generally not a testamentary substitute, so it is not part of the net estate. This is the genuine asset-protection scenario; a revocable trust offers no such protection. (Contrast the general overview in advanced NY estate planning techniques.) |
| Children benefit during your spouse’s lifetime | A QTIP must pay all income to the spouse first; an irrevocable trust can distribute among children and spouse simultaneously. |
| Your spouse is younger | A QTIP can lock your children out of any inheritance for decades while the surviving spouse receives income. An irrevocable trust or an immediate gift to the children may better match your intent. |
| Long-term care planning | Irrevocable trusts can be structured for Medicaid planning in ways a QTIP cannot. |
The trade-off is control: an irrevocable trust requires giving up ownership and revocability during life. That is precisely why it works for asset protection and why it is a serious decision, not a default.
Prenuptial and Postnuptial Agreements
The cleanest way to neutralize the elective share is a written waiver in a prenuptial agreement (signed before marriage) or postnuptial agreement (signed during marriage). Such an agreement typically waives the right of election against each other’s estates under EPTL § 5-1.1-A(e), identifies the separate property each spouse brought to the marriage, provides for support during marriage and at death, and specifies what happens to particular assets at death or divorce.
For enforceability in New York, the agreement must be in writing, signed, and acknowledged with the formality required for recording a deed. New York courts strictly enforce this acknowledgment requirement, and agreements lacking proper acknowledgment have been set aside. Full financial disclosure, the opportunity for independent counsel, and the absence of duress or overreaching are also essential. An agreement that fails these requirements leaves the elective share fully intact.
Building the Full Second-Marriage Plan
A comprehensive New York second-marriage plan usually combines these pieces:
| Component | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Prenuptial or postnuptial agreement | Addresses the elective share and identified assets. |
| Updated will and, where appropriate, a trust | Reflects the new marriage and the dual intent to provide for both the spouse and the children. |
| QTIP or irrevocable trust | Chosen based on the considerations above. |
| Coordinated beneficiary designations | Retirement accounts and life insurance override your will and are common testamentary substitutes. |
| Powers of attorney and health care proxies | Reflect the new family structure. |
| Communication with the children | Reduces the post-death conflict that drives Surrogate’s Court litigation. |
Common Mistakes in Second-Marriage Planning
| Mistake | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Assuming the new spouse will do the right thing | Even loving relationships change. Financial pressure, a later remarriage, or different views about how the children should be treated can override good intentions. Structure is more reliable than a promise. |
| Believing a revocable living trust protects assets from the spouse | It does not; revocable trust assets are pulled back into the net estate for the elective share. Only certain irrevocable structures provide true protection. |
| Forgetting beneficiary designations | A retirement account naming a prior spouse or the new spouse controls regardless of what the will says. |
| Skipping the prenuptial conversation | The awkwardness now is far smaller than the litigation later. |
| Leaving an outdated will in place | A will written before the second marriage that ignores the new spouse can produce major disputes, and under New York law a marriage does not automatically revoke a prior will the way some clients assume. |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my new spouse override my will in New York?
Partially, yes. Even if your will leaves your spouse nothing, your spouse can elect against the estate under EPTL § 5-1.1-A and claim the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate, including most non-probate (testamentary-substitute) assets. The only way to prevent this is a valid waiver, disqualification of the spouse, or leaving the spouse at least the elective-share amount outright.
Does a QTIP trust avoid the elective share?
No. Under EPTL § 5-1.1-A(a)(4), only property passing absolutely (outright) to the surviving spouse reduces the elective share; a lifetime income interest in a QTIP or other trust does not. The spouse can still elect to take the greater of $50,000 or one-third of the net estate outright, in which case the spouse’s interest in the trust is cut off. A QTIP remains the right vehicle for the balance of the estate, paired with a waiver in a prenuptial or postnuptial agreement or with an outright bequest to the spouse of at least the elective-share amount. The remainder still passes to your children at the spouse’s death.
Will moving assets into a living trust protect them from my new spouse?
No. Assets in a revocable living trust are testamentary substitutes and are included in the net estate for elective-share purposes. Revocable trusts help avoid probate but do not shield assets from a surviving spouse’s statutory rights.
Can I leave everything to my children and nothing to my spouse?
You can attempt to, but your spouse can still elect their statutory share unless they have validly waived it by prenuptial or postnuptial agreement, or are disqualified under EPTL § 5-1.2.
What happens if I die without updating my will after remarrying?
New York does not automatically revoke your prior will upon remarriage. An outdated will may distribute your estate in a way you no longer intend, while your new spouse retains the right of election, a combination that frequently leads to litigation among the spouse and the children.
Talk to us
Every family’s situation is different, and a plan that protects both your spouse and your children has to be built around yours. We draft QTIP and irrevocable trusts, prenuptial and postnuptial agreements and the wills that tie them together, and we litigate the elective-share disputes that follow when no plan was made. Call the Law Offices of Albert Goodwin at 212-233-1233 or email [email protected].
About the Author
Albert Goodwin Esq. is a licensed New York attorney with over 18 years of courtroom experience. His extensive knowledge and experience make him well-qualified to write authoritative articles on a wide range of legal topics. He can be reached at 212-233-1233 or [email protected].
