Mr. Goodwin is everything you want in an attorney: professional, honest, thorough, and genuinely caring. He always explains things clearly, so I understood exactly what was happening and what to expect next. His attention to detail and persistence really stood out. Looking back, I feel lucky to have found him. He guided me through the whole process expertly, and I deeply appreciate all his hard work. Would definitely recommend him to anyone needing legal help.
Call Today:
212-233-1233
SCPA 805: Powers of a Preliminary Executor
When a New York probate proceeding is delayed, most often because someone is contesting the will or because jurisdiction over all interested parties takes time to complete, the estate cannot simply sit unattended. Bills come due, property must be secured, and financial accounts need to be collected. To bridge this gap, the Surrogate’s Court can appoint a preliminary executor under SCPA 1412. But a preliminary executor does not have the full powers of an executor whose will has been admitted to probate. The most important limits come from SCPA 805, which governs a fiduciary’s powers over estate property, and from SCPA 1412(3) itself.
This page explains what a preliminary executor in New York can and cannot do, how SCPA 805(3) restricts dealings with real property, and how the appointment process works in Surrogate’s Court.
The Plain-Language Version
A preliminary executor is a temporary fiduciary, usually the person nominated as executor in the will, appointed while the probate proceeding is still pending. The appointment lets the estate function during a will contest or other delay. A preliminary executor generally has the rights and powers of an administrator: collecting assets, paying legitimate expenses, and preserving the estate (SCPA 1412(3); see also EPTL 11-1.1 for general fiduciary powers). A preliminary executor cannot pay legacies or make distributions to beneficiaries before the will is admitted to probate (SCPA 1412(3)).
Under SCPA 805(3), a preliminary executor may not sell, mortgage or otherwise dispose of the decedent’s real property without prior authorization from the Surrogate’s Court. A power of sale written into the will does not cure this, because the will has not yet been proved. SCPA 805(3) also protects specifically devised real property: property left to a named beneficiary should not be sold out from under that beneficiary without the beneficiary’s consent or a court order, typically granted only when other assets are insufficient to pay debts and administration expenses.
What SCPA 805 Means in Practice
SCPA Article 8 addresses the powers, duties and limitations of fiduciaries generally. SCPA 805(3) is the provision that matters most for real estate, and it has three practical effects.
1. Court approval is required for real property transactions
A preliminary executor, like a temporary administrator, holds a provisional appointment. Because no decree has established the validity of the will, SCPA 805(3) requires a court order before the preliminary executor can convey, mortgage or lease the decedent’s real property. This protects will contestants and beneficiaries from irreversible transactions made before the court decides whether the will is valid.
2. Good-faith purchasers are protected, but the fiduciary is not
SCPA 805(3) shields a purchaser who deals with a fiduciary in good faith and without knowledge of a defect in the fiduciary’s authority. The practical consequence: if a preliminary executor sells property improperly, the sale may stand as to an innocent buyer, but the preliminary executor faces personal liability (surcharge) to the estate for any resulting loss. Title companies in New York routinely refuse to insure a sale by a preliminary executor without a certified copy of the court’s authorizing order.
3. Specific devises receive special treatment
If the will leaves a particular parcel, for example “my house at 42-15 Example Street, Queens, to my daughter,” that property is specifically devised. A fiduciary should not sell it except with the devisee’s consent or court authorization, generally reserved for situations where the rest of the estate cannot cover debts, taxes and administration expenses.
What a Preliminary Executor Can and Cannot Do
| Permitted (SCPA 1412(3); EPTL 11-1.1) | Prohibited or Requires Court Order |
|---|---|
| Collect bank, brokerage, and retirement-payable-to-estate accounts | Paying legacies or distributing to beneficiaries before probate (SCPA 1412(3)) |
| Open an estate account and obtain an EIN | Selling, mortgaging, or disposing of real property without a court order (SCPA 805(3)) |
| Pay funeral expenses, administration expenses, insurance, and carrying costs | Selling specifically devised property without consent or court authorization (SCPA 805(3)) |
| Secure, insure, and manage real property; collect rents | Acting beyond any limitation the court places in the preliminary letters |
| Continue or wind down urgent business matters; pursue and defend claims on behalf of the estate | Self-dealing or using the appointment to gain advantage in the will contest |
A Worked Example
Suppose a decedent dies owning a house in Queens worth $650,000, a brokerage account of $400,000, and a checking account of $35,000. A disinherited son files objections to the will, and the contest is expected to take 14 months. The house has carrying costs of $4,200 per month (mortgage, taxes, insurance, utilities), roughly $58,800 over the life of the contest.
The nominated executor obtains preliminary letters under SCPA 1412. She may immediately collect the $400,000 brokerage account and $35,000 checking account into an estate account, pay the $14,500 funeral bill, insure the vacant house, and pay the monthly carrying costs from estate funds. She may not distribute anything to beneficiaries, and she may not sign a contract to sell the house, even though the will contains a power of sale, without first petitioning the Surrogate’s Court under SCPA 805(3). If continuing to carry the house would waste estate assets, that is precisely the showing she would make in her petition, on notice to the objectant and other interested parties.
How to Obtain Preliminary Letters in Surrogate’s Court
- File the probate petition. Preliminary letters are available only after the will has been filed and a petition for its probate is pending (SCPA 1412).
- Apply for preliminary letters. The application may accompany the probate petition or follow it. Priority generally goes to the executor(s) named in the will, in the order named; if a person with an equal or prior right is not joining, notice of the application must be given as required by SCPA 1412(2).
- Address the bond. The court will ordinarily require a bond under SCPA 1412(5) unless the will dispenses with one, and even then the court retains discretion to impose security or restrictions on the letters.
- Receive letters, possibly with limitations. The court may restrict the preliminary letters, for example by prohibiting collection of assets above a stated value or freezing specific accounts without further order.
- Act within the letters until probate concludes. Preliminary letters remain effective until the will is admitted to probate (when full letters testamentary issue), probate is denied, or the court revokes the appointment.
Our page on preliminary letters testamentary covers the application in more detail.
Common Pitfalls
| Pitfall | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Distributing too early | Paying beneficiaries before the probate decree violates SCPA 1412(3) and exposes the preliminary executor to surcharge if the will is later denied probate and the intestate distributees are different people. |
| Selling real estate without an order | The transaction may close against an innocent purchaser under SCPA 805(3), but the fiduciary bears personal liability, and most title companies will block the closing anyway. |
| Ignoring specific devises | Selling specifically devised property without consent or court approval invites objections at the accounting. |
| Poor recordkeeping | A preliminary executor must be able to account for every dollar received and spent if a beneficiary demands it or the court requires it, and a contested probate almost guarantees the account will be scrutinized. See our estate accounting pages. |
| Assuming commissions are automatic | Compensation for a preliminary executor is subject to the court’s oversight, particularly if the will is ultimately denied probate. |
The key statutes are SCPA 805(3) (restrictions on a fiduciary’s disposition of real property, protection of good-faith purchasers, and treatment of specifically devised property), SCPA 1412 (preliminary letters testamentary: who may receive them, notice, bond, powers and limitations), and EPTL 11-1.1 (general powers of fiduciaries over estate assets).
Estate Needs Action Before Probate Finishes?
We obtain preliminary letters so someone can secure assets, run the business or stop waste while a probate contest plays out, and we advise beneficiaries and objectants concerned about a preliminary executor’s handling of estate property. The Law Offices of Albert Goodwin has handled these matters in the New York Surrogate’s Courts since 2008. Call us at 212-233-1233 or email [email protected] for a consultation.
Related resources on this site: temporary letters testamentary, probate.
About the Author
Albert Goodwin Esq. is a licensed New York attorney with over 18 years of courtroom experience. His extensive knowledge and experience make him well-qualified to write authoritative articles on a wide range of legal topics. He can be reached at 212-233-1233 or [email protected].
